To avoid the reach of US copyright laws, numerous online pirates have set up shop in countries less willing or able to enforce intellectual property rights. ?Policymakers agree that these “*rogue” sites pose a real problem for US artists and rights holders who aren’t getting paid for the *rampant distribution of their music, movies and other creative works. The question is how to help them. Lawmakers keep offering proposals, but they don’t seem to be getting any closer to the right answer.